Tuesday, December 16, 2014
Pre-China Update
Friday, July 24, 2009
The state of magazine advertising.
A client recently asked me for my opinion of the state of the advertising industry, specifically as it relates to magazine advertising. Before you read my post, let me begin by stating that I love magazines! Runners World, Golf Digest, The New Yorker, Vanity Fair, Esquire the occasional impulse People purchase, BA, GMT etc. But at the same time, I can't remember the last time I looked at Time, SI, or even Business Week. To me newsmagazines are irrelevant. I get my news from CNN, ESPN, and local newspaper web sites, I don't read it in print. I have not re-subscribed to any magazine in years. Perhaps later I will try to figure out the "paid content" model on the web, but I don't think I'm smart enough.
Q: According a yesterdays article in btobonline.com, B-to-b advertising pages declined 31.6% in May compared with the year-earlier period.
· In broad strokes, how has your business been affected in the past 24-48 months?
· Are you seeing fewer advertisers? Or are the same numbers of advertisers spending less?
A: I believe my background is well suited to answer this question. I’ll limit my observations primarily to the last 10 years. I began advertising in 1993 and landed at IDG in 1996. By the time I left IDG in 2000 two major shifts occurred in theB2B advertising world.
First, IDG, Ziff and CMP lost their bread and butter (IT advertisers) to the business category, Fortune, Forbes, Business Week and the “new economy” titles that have all gone the way of the dodo. SAP, Oracle, Microsoft soon realized that IT was no longer a back office skunk works and to that end, IT people were marginalized and the CEO and CFO became squarely involved in the decision making process.
Second, the first dot com boom and bust. Every B2B publisher made a scramble to develop a web presence, but upstarts like Internet.com, Vertical Net, Tech Republic, All Business, Office.com, Business.com and a host of others offered access to the B2B community on the web, where, presumably business people spent time and money. Traditional publishers lost business and revenue to these “Hot” and “Cool” new companies. SO the same ad budgets (more or less) were sliced even thinner and across more properties. I made a fruitless jump to the web for a small business portal—Office.com. Unfortunately I learned that most of these start ups were “smoke and mirror” outfits, Office.com included.
I then had the fortune to work at the Fortune Group of Time Inc from 2000 through 2005 during a relatively stable advertising period (9/11 and the fallout notwithstanding). During this time a few other things happened that affected the business titles significantly. Specifically, the web grew up and web advertising began to have standards and metrics. The flight of IT to the business press slowed and to some extent returned to the IT mags, but companies like IBM and Sap and others found out that IT folks, specifically, lived online. User generated content began to significantly affect the decision making process. Tech Target, C-Net, and of course Google began to deliver quality content and strong advertising results.
From 2005 through 2008 I worked at Conde Nast as a Senior Account Manager at Golf Digest and then as a Corporate Sales Director in the Conde Nast Media Group. 05, 06, 07 Convinced much of the established B2B advertisers to swim further upstream. For example, Accenture, IBM, CDW, Bearing Point (RIP), Morgan Stanley, Charles Schwab etc. signed significant sponsorship deals with the PGA Tour and as a result, I and Golf Digest were beneficiaries. Conde was so bold as to launch Portfolio at this time, but sadly the timing couldn’t have been worse. Wired remained a beacon in the new economy. Unfortunately the “luxury” sell was not sustainable especially with the coming recession so the adjacent to business leisure titles (Golf, etc) quickly gave back all advertising gains from 2005-2008. They will never see the business category return with the same vigor. Get used to it.
So does this answer your question, no, but it is all cyclical and repetitive. I truly believe that the magazine (consumer and B2B) industry is doomed. Niche titles with small advertiser bases are dying left and right. News titles are suffering immensely as printed news has become irrelevant. The Web 2.0 experience has changed everything. We all get our news from somewhere.com.
Sure content is king and brand name reporters and journalists are important, but they are fleeing to the web and building their own web news outlets further fragmenting the advertising pool. Someone must make the gutsy move to make users pay for content a la the WSJ.com, but as the NYT has experienced and will experience, we have become accustomed to receiving our content and information for free. All B2B content providers need to develop a hybrid revenue model similar to the traditional advertising/subscription model that used to work.
In my opinion the only printed publications that will survive for a long time are those that people look forward to and linger over like Vanity Fairs, Harpers, The Atlantics and some fashion magazines. Should they survive they will never have “September” issues again. Revenue will be much more sobering. Publications full of news, reviews, speeds and feeds are doomed.
Presently, advertisers can get whatever they want and they can almost name their price. Great ideas always find funding, but the days of a splashy model or celebrity endorsing a PC are gone. B2B advertisers are demanding results—sales, leads, and at the very least response. If you cannot prove response then your days on a media plan are numbered. Web advertising continues to grow, albeit slowly this year too, because the best ads on the most focused sites deliver results so any Publisher, print, digital or other needs to insure the 3 c’s—content, community and collaboration are iron clad.
I recently read a study from Gartner that identified the habits of business executives. Of those surveyed, 85% read and sent email before they did any other work. To me that was very telling because I’m sure that 15 years ago that # 1 statement was to read the Journal or their business pages. The study went on to say that they go online for everything…business, pleasure and community. Most are active with social media. Magazine readership was very low on their daily activity list.
Magazines continue to raise rates with the rate of inflation because that’s as old as magazine advertising itself, the same way publishers continue to charge for bleed!!! How does that still happen?
The next disruptor in my mind is the Kindle. B2B publishers ought to be all over Amazon pleading to have their content included on the Kindle.
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
First Annual Taylors Lane Jingle Bell Jog
This past Saturday Mitch hosted a 1 mile (actually almost 1.2 mi) race for his friends. The race started on Taylors Lane by the side of our house and ran down Barrymore Lane to the end of Taylors Lane and back. It was really cold outside, about 20 degrees, but the sun was shining and the day was perfect. The winner was "Fast Eddie" Cohen, followed by Timmy Lelley, Shelby Hackenburg, Declan Flood, and Jacob Herrera.
Sunday, December 7, 2008
China Reunion 2008

Today Tracy, Mitch, Tess and I met up with the other adoptive families we met while in China in 2006. Since we were coming from NY, MA and RI we all met at the Mystic Aquarium in Mystic, CT. The girls, Mitch, Ben (another big brother who's 11) enjoyed the aquarium, especially the beluga whales followed by an early dinner at Mystic Pizza (the movie is 20 years old now). Her are a few pictures of the girls and their families. What's beautiful to see is the progress all of these wonderful girls have made and how happy they and their families are. We are all blessed by their presence and our lives are fuller and richer with each of them.
Sunday, November 30, 2008
Winter in Vermont
Here's something to ponder (courtesy of Bon Appetit)..."How come you never see turkey on the menus of any high-end restaurants?"
Sunday, November 23, 2008
The Turkey Trot
Today Mitch, Tess, Tracy and I got up to run the annual Mamaroneck Turkey Trot. Today, however the race temperature was unusually frosty...probably in the high 20's at the start.
Monday, November 10, 2008
The bitter Irony
.gif)
LAID OFF, Permanent Vacation, early retirement, victim of the recession.
So the bastards, aka "The Man" got to me on Friday. I was humming along as the Publisher of The History Channel Magazine delivering 67% growth over last year and 22% growth over my 2008 budget only to fall victim to the CEO's spreadsheet scalpel.
Monday, September 15, 2008
Reach The Beach 2008

So I haven't posted in a long time, all summer really. So I thought I would write about my annual adventure in New Hampshire, a 210 Mile 12-Person Running Relay race from Cannon Mountain to Hampton Beach, NH.
And a link to Turkey's photos:
http://gallery.me.com/dturkey#100517&view=carouseljs&sel=0
Wednesday, May 28, 2008
Celtic Pride


Here we are half way through game 5 of the Eastern Conference finals. As great as the Red Sox and the Patriots have been recently, the Celtics have been horrible...until this season. Today I went to the NBA store in NYC to get Mitch a Celtics jersey. Mitch has not been a bandwagon fan, he's been watching and following the Celtics all season. Unlike after the Super Bowl all the stupid NY fans have been very quiet. Here's to happy endings!